Hollywood has always confused me. They have perfectly good source material but often decide to move away from this. This doesn't just apply to Comics. In the past everyone always complained how the book was better than the movie, or which version of The Shining was best. Heck, Hollywood has even taken liberties with stories based on true events. Then again, I can understand how writers, directors, and producers want to stamp their individuality on what is, to them, a work of art. As such I will show you some of the differences in the comic book movies, and where I can, explain why these exist.
The Fantastic Four
Because this movie is one of many with a reboot, I will be detailing the differences in 3 parts. The original movie, the sequel, and the Reboot. These 3 movies remind me of the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.
The original movie was released in 2005. With only a few core differences in the movie from the comics, one could almost say this was "the Bad". Dealing with the origin story of the FF, a few changes were made which mostly made sense and really only affected Doom:
- Victor von Doom was included on the origin
- The FF were no longer accidentally bombarded by cosmic rays whilst flying, but rather went up to purposefully study a cloud of cosmic gas
- Doom was also affected by the cloud.
In the comics, Doom had nothing to do with the origin story of the FF. He was only in later years revealed to be a rival to Reed Richards. This change was a necessary change, as no FF villain is as known as Doctor Doom and I doubt anyone would want to watch them fight Moleman. Having Doom's powers originate from the cosmic cloud was also a strategic choice by Fox, as very few studios would dare tread in the realm of the Mystic/Supernatural. Doctor Doom was originally only a threat due to his vast amounts of money and technological progress. He was however at his best when he started mixing his tech with Mysticism.
"The Good", Rise of the Silver Surfer, managed to keep all the core elements of an important FF storyline. Once again there were several changes that were likely brought on by the previous movies success (if you can call it that).
- Cloud Galactus
- Inclusion of Doctor Doom
- Destruction of Galactus
In the Comics, Galactus is an enormous human-shaped entity that devours worlds in order to feed his hunger. The movie... a threatening cloud. This change was likely done to make the whole scene a little more believable for non-fans (Having a Giant Man would seem a little silly). The inclusion of Doom again built on the previous story line and allowed for a side story and proper fight scene before the confrontation of the Big Bad Cloud, this would have been seen as wanted by viewers. Finally in the Comics Galactus was not destroyed, but rather dissuaded by the FF's threat of using an all powerful weapon.
Lastly, we have "The Ugly". The reboot was universally panned by critics. Several rewrites and director changes resulted in the movie being almost unwatchable. The changes in this movie are so numerous that it is almost not even related to the comics (except that the four people gain the respective powers of the FF). This film changed the origin story, Doctor Doom, the family bond of Johnny and Sue, included the military, changed Ben Grimm's Yancy Street origins, and much more. If you want to ease into the comics, don't watch this one.